Reviewer onboarding checklist
Steps a new reviewer completes before accepting an invitation.
- Version0.1.0
- StatusDraft pending owner and counsel review
- EffectiveOn adoption by the owner through nexus-governance
- Applies toreviewer, steward-reviewer on all networks
- Text hash (sha256)a0df5f4f6eda089b…
- JurisdictionProposal: laws of Ontario and the federal laws of Canada applicable therein; for counsel review
Reports · the Global Centre for Risk and Innovation (GCRI Canada), publisher of record
Draft. Not in force.
This document is a draft. It is not legal advice and it is not in force. It becomes required only when the owner adopts it by a recorded decision in nexus-governance. Until then nothing here blocks anyone’s work.
Account and documents
- [ ] Account created on the network that invited you.
- [ ] Community Code of Conduct, Privacy Notice and Terms of Use accepted.
- [ ] Reviewer Charter and Confidentiality Agreement signed.
- [ ] Conflict-of-Interest declaration signed.
- [ ] Your reviewer profile filled in: subjects, languages, institutions, past coauthors. This is used to match you and to avoid conflicts.
The platform will not let you accept an invitation until these are current.
Before you accept
- [ ] You see reference, kind, due date and subjects only. Title and text show after you accept with no declared conflict.
- [ ] Check conflicts: author, same institution, coauthor, desk editor, any financial or personal link, any competing view you hold strongly.
- [ ] Check time. You need 14 days to accept, 28 days to report. The cap is 3 open reviews.
While you review
- [ ] Keep the manuscript confidential. Do not upload it or its parts to any AI tool.
- [ ] Do not contact the authors or share the manuscript.
- [ ] Judge the work on the pass you were asked for: evidence, method, stewardship, copy and claims, or release.
- [ ] Be specific and constructive. Say what is good, what must change, and what would change your view.
- [ ] Say if the work raises dual-use, ethics or integrity concerns.
Your report
- [ ] Result: pass, changes or fail, with reasons.
- [ ] Choose whether to sign. Notes become public after the decision.
- [ ] File before the due date. Ask for more time early.
After
- [ ] Your name appears in the yearly acknowledgement list only with your consent.
- [ ] You can download receipts, withdraw an acceptance, and ask for export or erasure.
- [ ] Concerns about the process go to the contact form.
Other charters of Reports.
Legal documents.
Maps, data and figures on this site are shown for context and general information. They are not advice, forecasts or warnings; the limits of the information are set out in the Disclaimers and Data Notices.
CC BY 4.0 Free to read. Text and figures: CC BY 4.0. Data: CC0 1.0. Authors keep copyright. Published by GCRI Canada.